Article Overview: Black Bears vs. Grizzly Bears
Alaska is home to a slew of furious furry giants, notably bears! Two of the most common bruin residents are the black bear (Ursus americanus) and the grizzly bear (Ursus arctos), often referred to as brown bears in coastal Alaska. These not so cuddly titans of the last frontier might seem similar at first glance, but look closer, and the differences are many. Wether you’re simply viewing bears or hunting them, it is important to be able to distinguish the two. In this article we’ll break down everything you need to know about black bears vs. grizzly bears.
Why Trust Us
AlaskaExplored is THE DESTINATION for all things Alaska. Whether you’re planning an epic moose hunting trip in Alaska, or you’re just curious about black bears vs. grizzly bears, we’ve got you covered. Here at AlaskaExplored.com you’ll find expert tips, detailed guides, stunning photographs, and so much more.
Together AlaskaExplored has more than twenty years of experience traveling, working, and exploring the beautifully rugged, 49th state. Working in television has taken us all around the world, and no place more than Alaska. During our time in Alaska we’ve documented countless stories from every corner and crevasse of the state.
We’ve helped showcase the grandeur of this wild place for National Geographic, Discovery, Disney, Animal Planet, and more. Now we want to share our knowledge and real life experiences with you!
My Experience with Black Bears vs. Grizzly Bears
I haven’t shot any animals in Alaska, but I have shot a lot of people shooting animals in Alaska. Instead of a rifle, my weapon of choice for the past decade has been a video camera. And while filming death isn’t my favorite part of the job, it’s fundamentally essential to the subsistence lifestyle. Life begets life, and I believe there are few purists more noble than providing for yourself and your community by independent sustenance harvesting.
While most sustenance living folks in Alaska don’t hunt bears, occasionally there’s someone who does. So suffice it to say, I’ve found myself on a handful of bear hunts in Alaska. Every hunt has been for black bears, as the overwhelming majority of people agree that hunting brown bears is cruel and pointless, as their meat is closer to inedible than a delicacy.
I’ve walked the slopes of Wrangell st. Elias filming cinnamon bear hunting and I’ve hiked the coastlines of south eastern Alaska in search of black bears. And even when I’m not filming a hunt we have to be conscious of bears. So for me and my crews, the biggest factor in the black bear vs. grizzly bear debate, is safety. In my experience, grizzly bears are much more of a threat than black bears.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear
Table of Contents
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Similarities
- Omnivores: Both black bears and brown bears are opportunistic omnivores. Their diet consists of a diverse blend of plant and animal matter, adapting to seasonal changes in food availability. Berries, nuts, insects, carrion, and fish are all on the menu, with salmon playing a crucial role in their summer diet.
- Hibernation: Alaskan winters are harsh, and both species hibernate for several months. They build dens in protected areas like caves, hollow trees, or excavated earth dens, emerging in the spring when food becomes available again.
- Solitary Creatures: These bears are generally solitary creatures, except for mothers raising their cubs. They maintain individual territories and avoid social interaction unless it involves mating or competition for resources.
- Ecological Importance: Both black bears and brown bears play a vital role in maintaining healthy ecosystems. By dispersing seeds through their scat and predating on smaller mammals, they contribute to a balanced predator-prey relationship.
- Similar Denning Behavior: Both species construct similar dens in various locations, such as caves, hollow logs, and excavated earth burrows. While brown bears tend to den in higher elevations, the basic denning behavior reflects their common evolutionary heritage.
- Similar Mating Rituals: Both black and brown bears exhibit similar courtship and mating behaviors. Males compete for females through displays of dominance and scent marking. Mating typically occurs in the spring or early summer, followed by a delayed implantation of the fertilized egg until fall.
- Conservation Status:: Listed as “Least Concern” by the IUCN due to their widespread distribution and adaptable nature. However, habitat fragmentation and human-bear conflicts pose ongoing challenges.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Physical Differences
Telling black bears from brown bears in Alaska is critical for both hunting regulations and safety. Mistaking a black bear for a grizzly during hunting season could lead to legal trouble, as they have different permit requirements and may even be off-limits in some areas. More importantly, understanding the difference is crucial for your safety in the wild. Black bears tend to be more timid, but grizzlies can be aggressive, especially when protecting cubs. Being able to identify the bear you encounter allows you to react appropriately – giving a black bear space might be enough, while a grizzly encounter might necessitate using bear spray or employing proper food storage techniques.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Size
Beyond color, one of the most obvious to determine black bear vs. grizzly bear, is size. Black Bears are smaller and lighter, typically weighing between 130-500 lbs. Brown Bears are significantly larger and more robust, with weights ranging from 400-1500 lbs.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Snout
Black bears have a “Roman nose” with a straighter profile, while brown bears boast a dished-in or “concave” snout, creating a more dramatic slope between their brow and nose.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Ears
Brown bears go for a subtler look with smaller, more rounded ears that almost blend into their head, they tend to be fuzzier or fluffier. Black bears, on the other hand, have larger, rounder ears that stick out more prominently, giving them a more alert appearance.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Coloration
Despite their name, black bears can exhibit a surprising range of color variations. Black is the most common, but they can also be brown, cinnamon, blonde, or even white (Kermode or Spirit bears). Meanwhile, Brown bears, as their name suggests, typically range in color from light brown to dark chocolate brown. However, some populations, like blonde grizzlies, have lighter fur.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Shoulder Hump
Brown bears have a prominent shoulder hump due to powerful shoulder muscles while black bears have no shoulder hump.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Claws
Black Bears have Shorter, curved claws, more suited for climbing trees, a common foraging strategy. Brown Bears have longer, straighter claws ideal for digging for roots, tubers, and small burrowing animals.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Tracks
Okay, now for black bear vs. grizzly bear tracks. Brown bear tracks are massive, leaving footprints up to 12 inches long. Look for long, straight claws that almost always leave marks, even on soft ground. Black bear tracks are generally 6-8 inches and more rounded or oval-shaped. Black bear claws are shorter and curved, often leaving no marks unless the ground is very soft.
Additionally, Grizzly bear tracks have more square front feet compared to black bears. If you place a straight edge across a grizzly’s front foot track just in front of the pad and behind the toe, it won’t cross over the toe on the other side. Black bear front tracks are more rounded, with a straight edge crossing over the toe on the opposite side of the foot.
Habitat & Range
When it comes to black bear vs. grizzly bear habitat and range in Alaska, both iconic inhabitants exhibit distinct preferences and in the state. Black bears are highly adaptable and can be found in a variety of habitats, including forests, tundra, and even urban areas. They are particularly abundant in southeastern Alaska’s coastal rainforests, where they forage for berries and salmon during the summer months.
Grizzly bears, on the other hand, tend to inhabit more remote and rugged terrain, such as alpine meadows, mountainous regions, and river valleys. They are most commonly found in coastal areas like Kodiak island or the interior and northern Alaska, where they feed on a diverse diet of berries, roots, and carrion. Despite these differences, both black bears and grizzly bears may overlap in their ranges, especially in areas with abundant food resources.
Behavioral Differences
- Parental Investment: While both species raise their young alone, black bear cubs emerge from the den at a younger age and remain with their mothers for about 16-18 months, learning vital survival skills. Brown bear cubs, however, are born smaller and stay with their mothers for up to 2.5 years, receiving a more extended period of parental guidance.
- Communication: Both species utilize a variety of vocalizations to communicate,including roars, growls, huffs, and whines. However, brown bears are known for their distinctive “bluffing vocalization,” a loud, exhaled whoosh used as a warning or threat display.
- Diet and Hunting Strategies: Both bears are technically omnivores, but their diets lean in different directions. Black bears are opportunistic eaters, with a menu that includes berries, nuts, insects, and even the occasional small mammal. Grizzlies, however, have a stronger carnivorous streak. While they do enjoy berries and vegetation, especially along the coast where salmon are plentiful, they’ll also hunt larger prey like caribou and moose.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Who Would Win in a Fight?
Now, for the fun part: who would win in a fight? In a head-to-head battle, the grizzly bear’s sheer size and strength would likely give it the upper hand. Black bears are smart enough to avoid confrontation whenever possible, and encounters usually involve the black bear backing down. However, black bears are fierce fighters if cornered. I wouldn’t want to fight either one of them.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Conclusion
In the grand scheme of things, there’s no real “winner” in this battle. Both black bears and grizzlies play vital roles in the Alaskan ecosystem. Black bears help disperse seeds through their scat, while grizzlies keep prey populations in check and influence vegetation patterns by digging for food. The true victory lies in humans understanding and respecting these magnificent creatures, ensuring they can continue to thrive in the Alaskan wild.
Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: Resources & References
For a list of our resources and for more info on black bears vs. grizzly bears, check out our resources and references here:
Alaska Department of Fish and Game
More Alaskan Articles
Alaskan King Bed: A Bed Size as Large as the State
Filming in Alaska: Everything You Need to Know + (Film & TV List)
National Baked Alaska Day: a Sweet February 1st Celebration!
[…] Black Bear vs. Grizzly Bear: What’s the Difference? […]